Exclusive Inventory

Relay partners directly with footwear brands and authorized retailers to acquire fit-based returns and surplus inventory.

Certified Pre-Owned

Our footwear experts rigorously inspect and select only the highest-quality, most desirable models for premium recommerce.

Refreshed and Refurbished

Every pair undergoes a rigorous quality check and cleaning process to ensure it looks, feels and performs like-new.

Lightning Fast Shipping

Place your order by 3 PM EST, and we’ll ship it out the same day. All orders ship within one business day.

Most Popular Footwear

View all
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics Gel-Cumulus running shoe in Rich Navy/Faded Orange, Medium (Regular) width
$84.99 $140.00
Women's Asics Gel-Cumulus 26, Rich Navy/Faded Orange, 6.5 B MediumAsics
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in Thirty Watt/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, Thirty Watt/Black, 12 D MediumNew Balance
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens On Cloudvista running shoe in Heather/Rhubarb, Medium (Regular) width
$99.99 $150.00
Women's On Cloudvista, Heather/Rhubarb, 9.5 B MediumOn
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in Thirty Watt/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, Thirty Watt/Black, 9 D MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, 9 D MediumNew Balance
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in White/Electric Indigo/Thirty Watt/Cosmic Rose, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, White/Electric Indigo/Thirty Watt/Cosmic Rose, 11 B MediumNew Balance
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Mens On Cloudvista running shoe in Creek/Mint, Medium (Regular) width
$99.99 $150.00
Men's On Cloudvista, Creek/Mint, 12 D MediumOn
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in Thirty Watt/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, Thirty Watt/Black, 13 D MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Inkwell/Heron Blue/Peach Blossom, Wide width
$79.99 $140.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Inkwell/Heron Blue/Peach Blossom, 11 D WideNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Grey Matter/Copper/Purple Fuchsia, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Grey Matter/Copper/Purple Fuchsia, 10.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, 9.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Grey Matter/Copper/Purple Fuchsia, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Grey Matter/Copper/Purple Fuchsia, 10 B MediumNew Balance
SEE ALL REVIEWS

Second Try Footwear

Relay sources fit-based returns, surplus inventory & footwear in imperfect boxes from authorized retailers and leading brands. Our footwear is practically perfect with zero-mileage normally hidden in warehouses and fulfillment centers.

Learn More

Fresh Listings

View all
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5 running shoe in Black/Bleached Lime Glo/Hot Mango, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5, Black/Bleached Lime Glo/Hot Mango, 12 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5 running shoe in Black/Mint Flash/White, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5, Black/Mint Flash/White, 13 D MediumNew Balance
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Womens Altra Lone Peak running shoe in Purple, Medium (Regular) width
$119.99 $140.00
Women's Altra Lone Peak 9, Purple, 9.5 B MediumAltra
Save $70.01
Side view on white background of Womens Saucony Triumph running shoe in Moon, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $160.00
Women's Saucony Triumph 22, Moon, 11 B MediumSaucony
Save $40.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam 860 running shoe in Black/Phantom, Extra Wide width
$99.99 $140.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v14, Black/Phantom, 9.5 2E Extra WideNew Balance
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Ghost running shoe in Ebony/Black/Yellow, Wide width
$124.99 $150.00
Men's Brooks Ghost 17, Ebony/Black/Yellow, 8 2E WideBrooks
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Revel running shoe in Black/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$69.99 $100.00
Men's Brooks Revel 8, Black/Black, 11 D MediumBrooks
Save $90.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance 1540 running shoe in Black/Harbor Gray, Wide width
$109.99 $200.00
Women's New Balance 1540v4, Black/Harbor Gray, 8.5 D WideNew Balance
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens On Cloudtilt running shoe in Flame/Eclipse, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $160.00
Women's On Cloudtilt, Flame/Eclipse, 5 B MediumOn
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens On The Roger Advantage Pro Clay running shoe in White/Cream, Medium (Regular) width
$114.99 $170.00
Women's On The Roger Advantage Pro Clay, White/Cream, 8 B MediumOn
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens On The Roger Advantage 2 running shoe in All Black, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $140.00
Women's On The Roger Advantage 2, All Black, 9.5 B MediumOn
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Mens On Cloudmonster Void running shoe in Silver/Lense, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $170.00
Men's On Cloudmonster Void, Silver/Lense, 11.5 D MediumOn

Certified Pre-Owned Footwear

We take the same care and attention you’d expect from CARMAX and apply it to performance footwear. Each pair is thoroughly inspected, cleaned, and ready to run, giving you all the benefits of new shoes without the price tag. Comes with a warranty too. Who says only vehicles deserve a second try?

SHOP PRE-OWNED

Footwear Under $100

View all
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics Gel-Cumulus running shoe in Rich Navy/Faded Orange, Medium (Regular) width
$84.99 $140.00
Women's Asics Gel-Cumulus 26, Rich Navy/Faded Orange, 6.5 B MediumAsics
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in Thirty Watt/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, Thirty Watt/Black, 12 D MediumNew Balance
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens On Cloudvista running shoe in Heather/Rhubarb, Medium (Regular) width
$99.99 $150.00
Women's On Cloudvista, Heather/Rhubarb, 9.5 B MediumOn
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in Thirty Watt/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, Thirty Watt/Black, 9 D MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, 9 D MediumNew Balance
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in White/Electric Indigo/Thirty Watt/Cosmic Rose, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, White/Electric Indigo/Thirty Watt/Cosmic Rose, 11 B MediumNew Balance
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Mens On Cloudvista running shoe in Creek/Mint, Medium (Regular) width
$99.99 $150.00
Men's On Cloudvista, Creek/Mint, 12 D MediumOn
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SuperComp running shoe in Thirty Watt/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$94.99 $150.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Pacer, Thirty Watt/Black, 13 D MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Inkwell/Heron Blue/Peach Blossom, Wide width
$79.99 $140.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Inkwell/Heron Blue/Peach Blossom, 11 D WideNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Grey Matter/Copper/Purple Fuchsia, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Grey Matter/Copper/Purple Fuchsia, 10.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 840 running shoe in Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 840v1, Vintage Indigo/Ginger Lemon/Chrome Blue, 9.5 D MediumNew Balance

Shop By Brand