Exclusive Inventory

Relay partners directly with footwear brands and authorized retailers to acquire fit-based returns and surplus inventory.

Certified Pre-Owned

Our footwear experts rigorously inspect and select only the highest-quality, most desirable models for premium recommerce.

Refreshed and Refurbished

Every pair undergoes a rigorous quality check and cleaning process to ensure it looks, feels and performs like-new.

Lightning Fast Shipping

Place your order by 3 PM EST, and we’ll ship it out the same day. All orders ship within one business day.

Most Popular Footwear

View all
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics Gel-Kayano running shoe in Black/Dark Currant, Medium (Regular) width
$144.99 $165.00
Women's Asics Gel-Kayano 32, Black/Dark Currant, 10 B MediumAsics
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Adrenaline running shoe in White/Black/White, Medium (Regular) width
$124.99 $150.00
Men's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 25, White/Black/White, 11 D MediumBrooks
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics Gel-Nimbus running shoe in Wave Teal/Illuminate Mint, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $165.00
Women's Asics Gel-Nimbus 27, Wave Teal/Illuminate Mint, 9 B MediumAsics
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Glycerin running shoe in Amparo Blue/Hyper Iris/Yellow, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $165.00
Women's Brooks Glycerin 22, Amparo Blue/Hyper Iris/Yellow, 9.5 B MediumBrooks
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens Asics Gel-Nimbus running shoe in White/Huddle Yellow, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $165.00
Men's Asics Gel-Nimbus 27, White/Huddle Yellow, 9.5 D MediumAsics
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Adrenaline GTS running shoe in Black/Black/Ebony, Wide width
$89.99 $140.00
Women's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 24, Black/Black/Ebony, 7.5 D WideBrooks
Save $40.01
Side view on white background of Womens Skechers Max Cushioning running shoe in Black/White, Medium (Regular) width
$64.99 $105.00
Women's Skechers Max Cushioning Elite-Smooth Transition, Black/White, 8 B MediumSkechers
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Clementine/Angora/Black Cement, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Clementine/Angora/Black Cement, 11.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics Novablast running shoe in Nature Bathing/Rubble Red, Medium (Regular) width
$124.99 $150.00
Women's Asics Novablast 5 TR, Nature Bathing/Rubble Red, 11 B MediumAsics
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Glycerin running shoe in Black/Grey/Rose Gold, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $165.00
Women's Brooks Glycerin StealthFit 22, Black/Grey/Rose Gold, 7.5 B MediumBrooks
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics GT-2000 running shoe in Blue Fade/Indigo Fog, Medium (Regular) width
$119.99 $140.00
Women's Asics GT-2000 14, Blue Fade/Indigo Fog, 10 B MediumAsics
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics GT-2000 running shoe in Blue Fade/Indigo Fog, Medium (Regular) width
$119.99 $140.00
Women's Asics GT-2000 14, Blue Fade/Indigo Fog, 9.5 B MediumAsics
SEE ALL REVIEWS

Second Try Footwear

Relay sources fit-based returns, surplus inventory & footwear in imperfect boxes from authorized retailers and leading brands. Our footwear is practically perfect with zero-mileage normally hidden in warehouses and fulfillment centers.

Learn More

Fresh Listings

View all
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5 running shoe in Black/Bleached Lime Glo/Hot Mango, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5, Black/Bleached Lime Glo/Hot Mango, 12 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5 running shoe in Black/Mint Flash/White, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5, Black/Mint Flash/White, 13 D MediumNew Balance
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Glycerin running shoe in Gray/Navy Peony/Fiery Red, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $165.00
Men's Brooks Glycerin 22, Gray/Navy Peony/Fiery Red, 12.5 D MediumBrooks
Save $55.01
Side view on white background of Mens Asics Gel-Nimbus running shoe in Indigo Fog/Denim Blue, Wide width
$109.99 $165.00
Men's Asics Gel-Nimbus 27, Indigo Fog/Denim Blue, 11.5 2E WideAsics
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Mens Asics GT-2000 running shoe in Gravel/White, Medium (Regular) width
$119.99 $140.00
Men's Asics GT-2000 14, Gravel/White, 11 D MediumAsics
Save $45.01
Side view on white background of Mens Asics Nimbus Mirai running shoe in White/White, Medium (Regular) width
$134.99 $180.00
Men's Asics Nimbus Mirai, White/White, 11 DAsics
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Ghost running shoe in Black/Black/Rose Gold, Medium (Regular) width
$129.99 $160.00
Women's Brooks Ghost Max 3, Black/Black/Rose Gold, 8.5 B MediumBrooks
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Adrenaline running shoe in Oyster/Green Gecko/Blue, Medium (Regular) width
$124.99 $150.00
Men's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 25, Oyster/Green Gecko/Blue, 7 D MediumBrooks
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Adrenaline running shoe in Silver Anniversary Edition, Medium (Regular) width
$124.99 $150.00
Women's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 25, Silver Anniversary Edition, 7 B MediumBrooks
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics Novablast running shoe in White/Fawn, Wide width
$124.99 $150.00
Women's Asics Novablast 5, White/Fawn, 10.5 D WideAsics
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Adrenaline running shoe in Primer Grey/Ebony/Jasmin, Extra Wide width
$124.99 $150.00
Men's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 25, Primer Grey/Ebony/Jasmin, 12.5 4E Extra WideBrooks
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Ghost 16 Weatherized running shoe in Country Blue/Winter Sky/Ebony, Medium (Regular) width
$129.99 $150.00
Men's Brooks Ghost 16 Weatherized, Country Blue/Winter Sky/Ebony, 15 D MediumBrooks

Certified Pre-Owned Footwear

We take the same care and attention you’d expect from CARMAX and apply it to performance footwear. Each pair is thoroughly inspected, cleaned, and ready to run, giving you all the benefits of new shoes without the price tag. Comes with a warranty too. Who says only vehicles deserve a second try?

SHOP PRE-OWNED

Footwear Under $100

View all
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Adrenaline GTS running shoe in Black/Black/Ebony, Wide width
$89.99 $140.00
Women's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 24, Black/Black/Ebony, 7.5 D WideBrooks
Save $40.01
Side view on white background of Womens Skechers Max Cushioning running shoe in Black/White, Medium (Regular) width
$64.99 $105.00
Women's Skechers Max Cushioning Elite-Smooth Transition, Black/White, 8 B MediumSkechers
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Clementine/Angora/Black Cement, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Clementine/Angora/Black Cement, 11.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Electric Jade/Reflection/Dark Silver Metallic, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Electric Jade/Reflection/Dark Silver Metallic, 9.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in White/Light Gold Metallic, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, White/Light Gold Metallic, 10.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $40.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam 860 running shoe in Grey Matter/Black, Wide width
$99.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v14, Grey Matter/Black, 10.5 2E WideNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Sea Salt/Vintage Indigo/Hot Mango, Wide width
$89.99 $165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Sea Salt/Vintage Indigo/Hot Mango, 6.5 D WideNew Balance
Save $70.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Ghost running shoe in Black/Black/Ebony, Medium (Regular) width
$99.99 $170.00
Men's Brooks Ghost 16 GTX, Black/Black/Ebony, 7 D MediumBrooks
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Black/Magnet, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Black/Magnet, 7 D MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Earth Shadow/Reflection/Urgent Red, Wide width
$89.99 $165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Earth Shadow/Reflection/Urgent Red, 8 D WideNew Balance
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Adrenaline GTS running shoe in Alloy/White/Zephyr, Narrow width
$89.99 $140.00
Women's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 24, Alloy/White/Zephyr, 7.5 2A NarrowBrooks

Shop By Brand